Alice in Wonderland
Disney ’s live - action remakes have been both praised for their imaginative re - imaginings of the original animated motion picture ( Maleficent , Cinderella ) and criticized for cashing in on nostalgia ( Aladdin , Lady and the Tramp ) . Although Disney ’s first live - action remake was the 1996 film101 Dalmatians , they did n’t jump producing them in solemn until fourteen years later with Tim Burton ’s 2010 filmAlice in Wonderland . The success ofAlice in Wonderland , which became the second highest grossing film of 2010 , prompt the studio to start rapidly announcing new live - action remakes of Greco-Roman animated films .
Some of Disney ’s resilient - action moving picture are more than just shot - for - shot remakes of the recreate movies but re-explain the news report , such asAlice in Wonderland , Maleficent , or the 2020 filmMulan . However , most of them are nearly utter copies of the enliven movies and replace hired hand - drawn vitality with either substantial actors or information processing system generated animals . Since most of the remakes are wildly successful at the box office , Disney has ramped up production — four more were unblock in 2019 alone .
concern : Mulan : What Disney+ ’s Live - Action Remake Does Better Than The Animated Original
For this higher-ranking , alive - action remakes are delimitate as a Disney flick using literal actors or photorealistic CGI that is inspire by a Disney animated flick . This ranking also excludes springy - activeness sequels , which include102 Dalmatians , Maleficent : schoolmistress of Evil , andAlice Through The Looking Glass . Here is every Disney live - natural process remaking ranked from unsound to good .
12. Dumbo (2019)
Tim Burton ’s direction ofDumbo , prompt by the 1941 revivify film , weighs down the whimsical story with overstuffed intent and a sinister , blue style . Part of the magical spell of the original motion-picture show is the hand - drawn vivification and adorable flying elephant , Dumbo . The springy - action at law remaking toss away those in party favour of a sprawling cast of characters that work at the Medici Brothers ' Circus , and Ehren Kruger further overcomplicates the plot of ground with his messy , imbalanced screenplay . Dumbois doubtlessly Disney ’s worst live - natural process remake , manage to get free of everything great about the original picture in central for a bizarre reinterpretation of the story .
11. Lady and the Tramp (2019)
Lady and the Trampis Disney ’s first remake to not receive a theatrical release , rather premiering only on Disney+ . The movie sport the voices ofTessa Thompson and Justin Theroux as Lady and Tramp , who are act as by tangible dogs with computer - generated faces recreate to match the negotiation . WhileLady and the Trampretains some of the appeal from the original moving picture , the remake suffers from a bizarre mixing of live creature and computer living that sends the movie straight into the weird valley . In addition , Lady and the Tramphas nothing young or original to say , making it a wholly unnecessary addition to the Disney moving picture canyon .
10. Alice in Wonderland (2010)
AlthoughAlice in Wonderlandwasn’t Disney ’s first live - action remaking , it ’s popularity inspired the trend — although the subsequence , Alice Through The Looking Glass , was a box office dud . Directed by Tim Burton , Alice in Wonderlandis slackly inspire both by the 1951 animated moving picture and Lewis Carroll ’s novel . Alice in Wonderlandis a very different picture from its invigorate predecessor and is characterized by Tim Burton ’s too - stylized direction , occasionally becoming overwhelmed by its own optic design . Alice in Wonderlandwas truly criticized for sacrifice narrative coherence in favour of way and a third number that buy the farm entirely off the rail , but it still manages to be a fairly enjoyable movie .
Related : Why Disney Really Started take in So Many Live - Action remake
9. Aladdin (2019)
Guy Ritchie ’s 2019 filmAladdinis almost a guessing - for - shot remake of the 1992 repair movie that added nothing raw to the story and did n’t assay to correctAladdin ’s confutable characterization of midway Eastern culture . Guy Ritchie was criticized for his direction of the film and specificallyAladdin ’s melodic number , which were either seemed to be queerly slow down ( " Prince Ali " ) or accelerate up in post - yield . The one shiny smear inAladdinisWill Smith ’s characterization of Genie , which had the follow the striking voice performance from Robin Williams in the original film . Will Smith ’s Genie brilliantly reinterprets the character , and his operation of " Friend Like Me " is one of the near parts of the otherwise forgettable moving-picture show .
8. Christopher Robin (2018)
Christopher Robinisn’t a direct remake of Disney’sWinnie the Poohfranchise , but a reimagining of the classical story . It comply Christopher Robin as an grownup , played delightfully by Ewan McGregor , as he loses his imagination and reconnects with his childhood self . Christopher Robinsuccessfully added a gloomy edge toWinnie the Poohby usher in Christopher ’s adult anxiety and mix them with the idle - hearted and philosophical stuffed bear , butChristopher Robinalso makes several crowing changestoWinnie the Pooh . The computer - generate vivification inChristopher Robinis significantly better than some of the other live - action remakes , and the moving-picture show is a warm and slimly forgettable addition to theWinnie the Poohfranchise .
7. 101 Dalmatians (1996)
Disney ’s original alive - action remake101 Dalmatianswas released in 1996 and starred Glenn Close as Cruella de Vil . Unlike the 1961 animate film it ’s free-base on,101 Dalmatiansdid not give any of the animals a speaking voice , centre instead on Rodger , Anita , and Cruella . Glenn Close ’s Golden Globe - name performance as Cruella is an over - the - top and campy delectation , managing to walk the credit line between nefarious and outright scary.101 Dalmatianswas a monumental commercial success for Disney , exalt the 2000 sequel102 Dalmatiansand the forthcoming prequel filmCruellastarring Emma Stone .
6. Mulan (2020)
One of Disney ’s most anticipated remaking , Mulanwas unloosen exclusively on Disney+ after its planned theatrical run was cancel due to the coronavirus pandemic . Mulandiffers significantly from the 1998 liven film and is a much better adaptation of the original verse form " The Ballad of Mulan . " AlthoughMulanwas initially criticized for curve the songs from the original film , Mulandid a lot of things better than its animated forerunner — include take a preponderantly Chinese dramatis personae , attractively choreographed activity sequences , and being more venerating of Formosan culture . However , Mulansuffers from try out to be faithful to the liven up movie while still seek to tell a new tale , and the result is a movie that ’s not cohesive at best and has major tonic whiplash at worst .
concern : Disney ’s Live - Action remake Should Focus On Its Bad Animated pic
5. The Lion King (2019)
The Lion Kingisn’t technically live - action , but rather a computer - generated and photorealistic remake of the original 1994 movie . Directed by Jon Favreau , The Lion Kingis essentially a slam - for - scene remake of the animated film , force additional inspiration from the design of the Broadway musical . While the movie was praise for its excellentvoice cast , which include Beyoncé , Seth Rogen , and Billy Eichner , the unoriginal CGI was criticized for its emotionless depictions of the characters . In contrast , the 1994The Lion Kinghad the trademark , expressive manus - pull animation that characterise all the film from the Disney Renaissance . Still , The Lion Kingis elevated by its excellent soundtrack , and while the CGI might not be groundbreaking it ’s still beautiful to look at .
4. Maleficent (2014)
Maleficent , which is loosely based on the 1959 filmSleeping Beauty , was the first - live action Disney remaking to take a radically different feeler to its reservoir fabric . Maleficenttells its story from the perspective of the scoundrel , with Angelina Jolie receiving praise for her appealing portrayal of Maleficent . Maleficentis full of arresting ocular effects and a uniquely churrigueresque stylisation of its fairytale world . The movie amply recrudesce both female leads — both Maleficent and Aurora , who is played with heartbreaking vulnerability by Elle Fanning . WhileMaleficentstumbles in places due to the overwrought melodic score and overused CGI , it turnsSleeping Beautyinto a complex write up about motherhood and trauma .
3. The Jungle Book (2016)
Jon Favreau’sThe Jungle Bookis one of the few Disney remakes to receive almost universal plaudits , with picky kudos for the stunningly rendered data processor - generate brute and the phenomenal voice casting . WhileThe Lion Kingwas criticize for not add anything original to the level , The Jungle Bookweaves in stirring from both the 1967 animated movie and Rudyard Kipling ’s original storey collection . Thevisual effects inThe Jungle Book , unlikeThe Lion King , manage to create a sense of admiration without looking unrealistic , and the movie remains faithful to the unruly spirit of the original cinema .
2. Beauty and the Beast (2017)
Beauty and the Beastfaithfully adapted the 1991 revivify plastic film , and add together in several songs from the popular Broadway musical . Although the film is like to the liven up movie , it was able to revitalise the story and add legitimate excited depth , anchor by Emma Watson ’s portrayal of Belle and Dan Stevens as the Beast . By incorporating Sung dynasty from both the beloved alive film and the Broadway musical , such as the Beast ’s solo " Evermore,“Beauty and the Beastcreated a richly textured and more nuanced world than in the original movie . knockout and the Beastis both a wonderful re - imagining of the 1991 animated picture show and a visually lush , romantic motion-picture show that can stand on its own .
Related : How Each Disney Princess Is change From Their Original Fairytale
1. Cinderella (2015)
The good bouncy - activity Disney remake is undoubtedly the 2015 filmCinderella , which premiered to universal acclaim for it ’s direction , musical score , costume intent , faithfulness to the 1950 animated moving-picture show , and carrying into action from Lily James , Cate Blanchett , and Richard Madden . Directed by Kenneth Branagh , Cinderellasuccessfully update the outdated animated flick while maintaining its nostalgic , romantic feeling . Branagh capture Ella ’s raw aroused depth without overloading the script or losing control of the movie ’s direction , andCinderellamaintains it ’s classic charm without weaken the main character . Cinderellais a beautifully design cinema that strike the deliberate proportion between fidelity to the original film while still telling a refreshing story .
Disney ’s live - natural process remakes range from nearly unwatchable movies to joyful adaptations that maintain the spirit of the original . The sound remakes do n’t just re-create the animated film they ’re inspired by — but find a way to breathe Modern biography into them , and re - imagine them for a New interview . While Disney will stay putting out new bouncy - activity remake — includingHerculesandThe small Mermaid , just to name a few — hopefullyDisneycan go on to create magic trick with their reimagined classics .
Next : Why Mulan Is A Disney Princess ( Despite Not Actually Being Royalty )
